The Impact of Air Pollution, Including Asian Sand Dust, on Respiratory Symptoms and Health-related Quality of Life in Outpatients With Chronic Respiratory Disease in Korea: A Panel Study

Article information

J Prev Med Public Health. 2018;51(3):130-139

Publication date (electronic) : 2018 May 9

doi : https://doi.org/10.3961/jpmph.18.021

Motoyuki Nakao¹, Yoko Ishihara^,1, Cheol-Hong Kim², In-Gyu Hyun²

¹Department of Public Health, Kurume University School of Medicine, Kurume, Japan

²Department of Internal Medicine, Respiratory Health Center, Hallym University Dongtan Sacred Heart Hospital, Hwaseong, Korea

Corresponding author: Yoko Ishihara, PhD Department of Public Health, Kurume University School of Medicine, 67 Asahimachi, Kurume, Fukuoka 830-0011, Japan E-mail: blackcat@med.kurume-u.ac.jp

Received 2018 January 25; Accepted 2018 April 17.

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

Both acute and chronic exposure to air pollution are known to have detrimental effects on cardiorespiratory health [1]. Worsening air pollution in northeast Asia, including Korea and Japan, is believed to be due to long-range transport of air pollutants from industrialized areas of mainland China [2,3], as well as domestic sources of air pollution such as motor vehicles, industry, and open burning [4,5]. In addition to anthropogenic air pollutants, a natural phenomenon known as Asian sand dust (ASD) causes air pollution in East Asia. ASD particles originating from inland China, including the Gobi and Taklamakan deserts and the Loess Plateau, are transported to East Asia with the westerlies and monsoon mainly in the spring, accompanied by pollutants produced in industrial areas on the east coast of China [6,7]. Ambient nitrate and sulfate concentrations have been reported to remain high, accompanied by long-lasting high ambient particulate matter (PM) concentrations, during ASD events in Korea and Japan [8]. Lee et al. [9] reported that the microbial profiles of ambient particles during ASD events were distinctive from those observed during non-ASD events, suggesting that ASD might cause adverse health effects in areas covered with ASD particles. PM air pollution has been reported to have health effects in terms of mortality and morbidity from cardiorespiratory diseases, respiratory symptoms, and hospital admissions [10-13]. In the estimation of effects on the atmospheric environment, which is intimately involved in daily life, objective and clinical endpoints, as well as a multifaceted evaluation including a subjective measure of impact, are desirable. Therefore, the concept of health-related quality of life (HR-QoL), which refers to an individual’s perception of well-being, should also be considered as a health outcome of exposure to air pollution [14]. Although Yamazaki et al. [15] reported a significant linear trend of lower HR-QoL vitality scores on the Short Form-36 Health Survey (SF-36) in groups exposed to higher concentrations of nitrogen oxides in Japan, few studies have investigated the effects of air pollution on HR-QoL in Korea.

To elucidate the association of air pollution levels with patients’ reported respiratory symptoms and HR-QoL, we conducted a hospital-based panel study of patients with or without chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) living in Dongtan, Hwaseong, which is 30-40 km south of Seoul.

METHODS

RESULTS

Characteristics of Participants and Air Quality During Survey Period

The characteristics of participants at the baseline (February) are presented in Table 1. The mean age, male-to-female ratio, and smoking rate in the COPD group were significantly higher than in the referent group. A significant mean age difference was found only in male participants. Body mass index and employment were significantly lower in the COPD group than in the referent group. While hay fever and self-reported asthma were more prevalent in the COPD group than in the referent group, this difference was not significant. About half of the COPD patients were classified as GOLD stage II (moderate), after which GOLD stage I (mild), III (severe), and IV (very severe) were most prevalent, in decreasing order. Air quality and climate data during the survey period are summarized in Table 2 and Figure S1.

Table 1.

Characteristics of participants at baseline, 2013-2015

Table 2.

Summary of air quality and climate data¹ at each survey

Comparison Of HR-QoL Scores and Respiratory Symptoms Between the COPD and Referent Groups

Table 3 shows that for each month, physical fitness, overall health, and quality of life scores on the COOP/WONCA charts were significantly worse in the COPD group than in the referent group. Daily activity scores on the COOP/WONCA charts were only worse in the COPD group than in the referent group in July. In February, all SF-36v2 subscale scores excluding mental health scores were worse in the COPD group than in the referent group. Four kinds of respiratory symptoms were more prevalent in the COPD group than in the referent group, and the number of symptoms per participant was higher in the COPD group than in the referent group.

Table 3.

Comparison of HR-QoL scores and respiratory symptoms between COPD and referent groups in each season

Factors Associated With Respiratory Symptoms, COOP/WONCA Chart Scores, and SF-36v2 Subscale Scores

The associations of ambient air quality with COOP/WONCA chart scores, SF-36v2 subscale scores, and respiratory symptoms were examined using GEE analysis (Figure 1). After adjusting for demographics, lifestyle, disease severity, temperature, and humidity, it was found that ASD events were associated with lower physical fitness COOP/WONCA chart scores. Increased PM₁₀ concentrations were related to worse daily activity COOP/WONCA chart scores. The relationship between daily activities and PM_2.5 parameters could not be examined because PM_2.5 parameters did not fit this GEE model. Regarding the SF-36v2 subscales, higher PM_2.5 and NO₂ concentrations were associated with lower social functioning scores, and higher NO₂ concentrations were correlated with lower mental health scores. Higher PM₁₀, NO₂, and O₃ concentrations were related to affirmative answers to symptom Q1 (Does the weather affect your cough?), and higher PM₁₀ concentrations were associated with affirmative answers to symptom Q4 (How frequently do you wheeze?).

Figure. 1.

Factors associated with COOP/WONCA chart scores (A), SF-36v2 subscale scores (B), and respiratory symptoms (C) analyzed by generalized estimating equations. Data are presented as odds ratios (ORs) (black square, crude OR; white square, adjusted OR) with 95% confidence intervals. Crude ORs show the associa- tions between pollutant concentrations (in 10 µg/m³ [PM₁₀, PM_2.5] or 10 ppb [NO₂, O₃] increments), ASD events during the past month, temperature (in 10°C incre- ments), or RH (in 10% increments) and the dependent variables. The adjusted ORs were adjusted for age, sex, body mass index, smoking status, COPD severity, use of air cleaning equipment, time spent outdoors, ambient temperature, and RH. Adjusted ORs of COPD severity are presented on the right side of each panel. De- tailed data are presented in Tables S2-S4. COOP-WONCA, Dartmouth Coop Functional Health Assessment/World Organization of National Colleges, Academies, and Academic Association of General Practitioners; SF-36v2, Short Form-36 Health Survey version 2; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; RH, relative humidity; PM₁₀, particulate matter less than 10 μm in diameter; PM_2.5, particulate matter less than 2.5 μm in diameter; NO₂, nitrogen dioxide; O₃, ozone; ASD, Asian sand dust; ppb, parts per billion. *p<0.05.

DISCUSSION

We conducted a hospital-based panel study of Korean adults to try to predict the impact of air pollution on 75 participants with COPD and 90 participants without respiratory diseases (Table 1). We used GEE analysis to predict the association between air pollution and health status because this study consisted of an iterative survey. Some significant associations of air quality parameters with HR-QoL and respiratory symptoms were found in this study (Figure 1).

Children, elderly people, and patients with respiratory disorders are considered highly susceptible to air pollution [13]. Morbidity, mortality, hospital admission, and cardiorespiratory symptoms were therefore analyzed as health outcomes of air pollution. Patients with COPD, which elderly people are prone to, presented a significant association between increased mortality and hospitalization due to disease exacerbation from short-term exposure to ambient fine PM [27]. In addition to clinical and objective endpoints, HR-QoL changes should also be considered as a health outcome of exposure to air pollution [14]. Although few reports have investigated the relationship between air pollution and HR-QoL, Yamazaki et al. [15,28] reported that higher nitrogen oxide and oxidant concentrations were associated with lower vitality scores on the SF-36 in Japan. Our previous study showed that HR-QoL in Mongolian adults with respiratory diseases was worse in the cold season, when air pollution is severe [29,30]. Kamimura et al. [31] reported that perceived environmental pollution levels were associated with HR-QoL, but with different patterns among 3 East Asian countries (China, Japan, and Korea). These reports suggest that HR-QoL may be a useful measure to assess the impact of air pollution on public health, although international differences exist.

Seasonal variations in the clinical conditions of COPD have been reported, with more patients suffering exacerbations in winter [32,33]. Miravitlles et al. [34] reported that HR-QoL in COPD patients was better in spring/summer than in the winter. In the present study, temperature and humidity were included as independent variables in the model to analyze seasonal factors. Higher temperatures were significantly associated with worse scores of physical functioning, role: physical, and general health perception subscales of the SF-36v2, while the COOP/WONCA daily activities score worsened in association with lower temperatures (Figure 1). Our results are not consistent with previous reports [32-34], except for the COOP/WONCA daily activities score. We speculate that this inconsistency is attributable to the survey being started in winter. Only COPD patients in a stable state even in winter were included, so this set of patients may not have been susceptible to exacerbation. The cause of the association between higher temperatures and worse HR-QoL remains unclear.

ASD events were significantly associated with lower physical fitness scores on the COOP/WONCA charts, even after adjustment (Figure 1). COOP/WONCA physical fitness scores were also associated with COPD severity, suggesting that physical fitness in the COPD patients was more vulnerable to exposure to ASD events than in the referent group. The association of COOP/WONCA daily activity scores with PM₁₀ was independent of COPD severity. All SF-36v2 subscales were significantly associated with COPD severity. Additionally, social functioning subscale scores on the SF-36v2 were related to PM_2.5 and NO₂ concentrations, suggesting that social functioning in the COPD group was more vulnerable to exposure to these pollutants than in the referent group. The “weather affects your cough” symptom was associated with PM₁₀, NO₂, and O₃ concentrations but not with COPD severity, while the “frequent wheezing” symptom was correlated with PM₁₀ and COPD severity. These results suggest that PM₁₀ and gaseous pollutants such as NO₂ and O₃ cause weather-related cough, leading to the deterioration of daily activities, and this cascade of reaction to PM₁₀ exposure is suggested to occur independently of COPD. In contrast, PM₁₀ is also suggested to cause wheezing, leading to the deterioration of physical fitness and social functioning, and COPD patients appear to be more susceptible to PM₁₀ than those without COPD. PM_2.5 was also associated with frequent wheezing after adjustment, but not to a significant extent. ASD events were not significantly associated with any symptoms, though they were associated with the HR-QoL physical fitness score. The main component of ASD is soil-derived PM, including PM₁₀, and PM_2.5 [35]. Therefore, ASD events might have some impact on symptoms such as coughing and wheezing, thereby worsening the daily activity, physical fitness, and social functioning aspects of HR-QoL. Additionally, increased O₃ concentrations were associated with weather-related cough, independent of COPD severity. However, O₃ did not show any adverse effects on HR-QoL—instead, lower O₃ concentrations were associated with lower COOP/WONCA physical fitness scores in an obscure way. Since O₃ is a substance temporarily produced due to the interaction of volatile organic compounds or nitrogen oxides with ultraviolet rays [36], the association of NO₂ with social functioning and mental health might be related to fluctuations in ambient O₃ concentrations. The differences in the effects of gaseous pollutants and PM on respiratory symptoms might be explained in terms of the physical and chemical properties of these pollutants and pathophysiological and physiological differences between the participants with and without chronic respiratory diseases [37,38].

There were several limitations of this study. First, the sample size was relatively small, which may be why few parameters showed a significant association with symptoms and HR-QoL scores. Second, since this was a panel study, the participants were not strictly followed. The causal relationship between HR-QoL and air quality parameters remains unclear, although more insight was obtained through comparisons with cross-sectional studies. Third, although the odds ratios were adjusted for various factors to estimate the association of environmental exposure with symptoms and HR-QoL in the GEE analysis, unknown confounders may have been present because this study was conducted with a small sample. Finally, although air quality data were obtained from monitoring stations near the hospital, it was impossible to verify a consistent relationship between each participant’s range of movement and the location of the station. To evaluate the relationship between air pollution and health outcomes accurately, it would be necessary to measure indoor air quality and personal exposure to air pollution.

In conclusion, this study reported that PM air pollution may cause respiratory symptoms, leading to HR-QoL deterioration, in a sample of Korean participants. While some adverse effects of air pollution appeared to occur regardless of COPD, others appeared to occur more often and with greater severity among COPD patients. The public sector, therefore, needs to consider tailoring air pollution countermeasures to people with different health conditions to minimize adverse health effects.

SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIALS

Article information Continued