1Department of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA
2MGH Institute for Technology Assessment, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA
Copyright © 2024 The Korean Society for Preventive Medicine
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest associated with the material presented in this paper.
Funding
None.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization: Sung M, Jalali MS, Rees VW. Data curation: Sung M. Funding acquisition: None. Methodology: Sung M, Rees VW. Jalali MS. Writing – original draft: Sung M. Writing – review & editing: Sung M, Lee H, Rees VW, Jalali MS.
Source | Data elements | Years1 | Population | Availability | Variables related to SU | Strengths | Limitations | Studies using the data |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Korean Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service (HIRA) [47] | Prescription and claims data | 2009-1 y prior to present | Patients who use national health insurance; HIRA receives and evaluates claims from 98% of the Korean population | Accessible with application and fee (e.g., via virtual network or data centers); Various types of data by patient characteristic: National Patient Sample, Aged Patient Sample; tailored extraction of data available | Substance prescription (opioids, benzodiazepines, etc.), medical claims, diagnosis codes | • Nationally representative sample | • Captures national health insurance users | [21,22,26] |
• Opioid analgesic prescriptions | • Medication and prescription data considered to be of comparatively high validity [48] | • Cannot reveal temporal trends by patient since data are de-identified | ||||||
• Electronic health records | • Detailed clinical data | • Cannot monitor illicit use; addiction poorly documented in diagnosis codes | ||||||
• Patient characteristics | • Socioeconomic variables are limited (e.g., codes for being under the poverty level) | |||||||
• Other prescriptions and comorbidities | • Only cross-sectional research available | |||||||
National Health Insurance Service (NHIS) [49] | Prescription and claims data | 2002-2019 | Patients who use national health insurance; NHIS is the national insurer of medical services | Accessible with application, fee, and place restrictions (e.g., via virtual network or data centers); Various types of data by patient characteristic: sample cohort, medical examination cohort, aged cohort; tailored extraction of data available | Substance prescription (opioids, benzodiazepines, etc.), medical claims, diagnosis codes | • Nationally representative sample | • Captures national health insurance users | [20,28,29,33,38-42] |
• Opioid analgesic prescriptions | • Medication and prescription data considered to be of comparatively high validity [48] | • Does not include data of non-benefit users | ||||||
• Electronic health records | • Detailed clinical data | • Cannot monitor illicit use; addiction poorly documented in diagnosis codes | ||||||
• Patient characteristics | • Enables longitudinal data analysis by patient | |||||||
• Other prescriptions and comorbidities | • More specified socioeconomic variables possible (e.g., geocoding) | |||||||
• Medical histories | ||||||||
Narcotics Information Management System [50] | Imports and exports | 2018-present | Mandatory reporting by all narcotic handlers, collecting over 120 million cases annually | Partially accessible with application through medical narcotics big data utilization service, data provided for a maximum of 1 y | Four datasets are separately available (import/export, production, sales/ purchase, and usage) | • Large sample size | • Cannot reveal temporal trends by patient since data are de-identified | [51] |
Distribution | • Holistic data collection across substance distribution systems | • Cannot reveal annual trends since data are only provided for a maximum of 1 y | ||||||
• Pharmaceutical companies | • Nationally representative sample | |||||||
• Wholesalers Prescription and dispensation data | ||||||||
• Hospitals, clinics, pharmacies | ||||||||
Report on Public Awareness of Misuse of Drugs [52] | • Perceptions on SU | Yearly reports, 2006-1 y prior to present | Web panel and phone call samples from Entire Korean population Response rate around 5%; final sample size 1000 | Report accessible through website | Q10. Experience with weight loss drugs, brain stimulants (“study aids”), other narcotics (e.g., marijuana, methamphetamine), “sobering drugs,” and synthetic novel drugs | • Yearly report | • No access to raw data | |
• Experiences of SU Statistics are reported by sex/gender and region | • Estimates of total SU prevalence in Korea | • Drug use assessed in broad categories | ||||||
• Low response rate, possible bias from data acquirement methods | ||||||||
Q11. Experience requesting over-prescription of substances | • Socioeconomic variables other than sex/gender and region not available | |||||||
Korea Adverse Events Reporting Systems Database (KAERS DB) [53] | Detection of substance misuse & morbidity | 1988-2 y prior to present | Cases reported through KAERS | Partially accessible with application (data are only within 10 y) | Demographics, substance code, results, doses and usage pattern, route of administration, indications, purpose of drug usage, adverse event information, medical history | • Nationally representative sample | • Potential underreporting (reporting usually done by healthcare providers) | [23,24,35,54] |
• Patient characteristics | ||||||||
• Type of adverse event | • Difficult to observe illicit SU | |||||||
• Mechanisms of SU | ||||||||
Narcotic Crimes Report (Prosecution Service) [4] | No. of cases of trafficking, use, or possession of an illicit substance (opioids, heroin, cocaine, amphetamine/ATS/NPS, cannabis) | Yearly reports, 2004-1 y prior to present | Cases identified and secured in law enforcement operations | Report accessible through website | N/A | • Yearly report | • No access to raw data | |
• Some data that could be used to estimate illicit drug use | • Limited to drug offenders; influenced by policies and political environment | |||||||
• Frequently cited by media (high social influence) | ||||||||
Korea Youth Risk Behavior Web-based Survey (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) [55] | Detection of SU morbidity | Every 3 y between 2005-2010, annually since 2011 | Sample of 2% of total middle and high school students (average n=77 105) | Reports, public-release research dataset | Alcohol use, mental health, SU (lifetime SU; reasons for SU; first SU) | • Focused on the youth population, which is suspected to be experiencing the most rapid SU increase | • Sample is restricted to students enrolled | [43-46] |
• Limited variables on SU | ||||||||
• Routine data collection | • Likely to be underreported | |||||||
Discharge Injury Patient Survey (Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency) [56] | Detection of substance misuse & morbidity | 2005-2 y prior to the present | Patient sample of 9% from 220 sampled hospitals (approximately n=300 000) | Public research dataset accessible with application | Demographics, diagnostic code, result of treatment, reason of injury (e.g., “poisoning”), type of poison substance | • Large sample size | • Frequent measurement error and misclassification of SU | |
• Inpatient stays | • Detailed clinical data and few missing data | |||||||
• Electronic health records | • Self-reported variables included | |||||||
• Diagnostic codes for non-fatal overdose | ||||||||
Emergency Room Injury Survey (Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency) [57] | Detection of substance misuse & morbidity | 2006-2 y prior to the present | All patients who visited 23 sample ERs (approximately n=280 000) | Public research dataset (year 2019, 2020) accessible with application | Demographics, diagnostic code, result of treatment, reason of injury (e.g., “poisoning”), type of poison substance, suicide risk factor (e.g., “drug addiction”) | • Nationally representative sample | • Frequent measurement error and misclassification of SU | |
• ER visits | • Includes the substances used | • Occupation/education documented for only 10% to 20% of sample | ||||||
• Diagnostic codes for non-fatal overdose | • Requires cleaning of manually entered data | |||||||
• Only 2 y publicly available | ||||||||
Mental Health Survey (Research and Planning Division of the Mental Health Research Institute) [58] | Detection of SU morbidity | Every 5 y (2001-2021) | Those aged 18 y to 79 y (n=5511) (2021) | Reports, public-release research dataset; Restricted dataset accessible with application | Alcohol use disorder, nicotine use disorder, suicide (2011, 2016, 2021), SUD (2016) | • Data collection extended for several years | • SUD only documented in 2016 | |
• Used in several mental health-related studies | ||||||||
Cause of Death Survey (Statistics Korea) [59] | Mortality data | Every year/month | Death, includes all reported cases | Publicly available | Death by poisonous substance, death by unknown substance, suicide by other method | • Regional/monthly data | • Does not specify substance | |
• Cause of death demographics | • Nationally representative sample | • Cause of death not sufficiently specific |
Report | Year | Study population | Content |
---|---|---|---|
Substance User Survey [5] | 2021 | 540 Adult offenders sampled from rehabilitation facilities or undergoing SUD treatment | Type of substance, SU period, gender, education, income/wealth, previous health issues, comorbid conditions, childhood experience, age of SU initiation, purchase route, etc. |
Mental Health Survey [60] | 2016 | Households from 21 community catchments throughout Korea | Past usage of any substances |
Narcotic Substances Addiction Survey [61] | 2014 | 936 Adults living in Incheon | SU prevalence estimates in Incheon |
Narcotic Substances Addiction Survey [62] | 2009 | 447 People with drug dependence in prisons, rehabilitation facilities, probation systems, and other hospital systems | Type of substance, SU period, gender, education, income/wealth, previous health issues, comorbid conditions, childhood experience, age of SU initiation, purchase route, etc. |
Source | Data elements | Years |
Population | Availability | Variables related to SU | Strengths | Limitations | Studies using the data |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Korean Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service (HIRA) [47] | Prescription and claims data | 2009-1 y prior to present | Patients who use national health insurance; HIRA receives and evaluates claims from 98% of the Korean population | Accessible with application and fee (e.g., via virtual network or data centers); Various types of data by patient characteristic: National Patient Sample, Aged Patient Sample; tailored extraction of data available | Substance prescription (opioids, benzodiazepines, etc.), medical claims, diagnosis codes | • Nationally representative sample | • Captures national health insurance users | [21,22,26] |
• Opioid analgesic prescriptions | • Medication and prescription data considered to be of comparatively high validity [48] | • Cannot reveal temporal trends by patient since data are de-identified | ||||||
• Electronic health records | • Detailed clinical data | • Cannot monitor illicit use; addiction poorly documented in diagnosis codes | ||||||
• Patient characteristics | • Socioeconomic variables are limited (e.g., codes for being under the poverty level) | |||||||
• Other prescriptions and comorbidities | • Only cross-sectional research available | |||||||
National Health Insurance Service (NHIS) [49] | Prescription and claims data | 2002-2019 | Patients who use national health insurance; NHIS is the national insurer of medical services | Accessible with application, fee, and place restrictions (e.g., via virtual network or data centers); Various types of data by patient characteristic: sample cohort, medical examination cohort, aged cohort; tailored extraction of data available | Substance prescription (opioids, benzodiazepines, etc.), medical claims, diagnosis codes | • Nationally representative sample | • Captures national health insurance users | [20,28,29,33,38-42] |
• Opioid analgesic prescriptions | • Medication and prescription data considered to be of comparatively high validity [48] | • Does not include data of non-benefit users | ||||||
• Electronic health records | • Detailed clinical data | • Cannot monitor illicit use; addiction poorly documented in diagnosis codes | ||||||
• Patient characteristics | • Enables longitudinal data analysis by patient | |||||||
• Other prescriptions and comorbidities | • More specified socioeconomic variables possible (e.g., geocoding) | |||||||
• Medical histories | ||||||||
Narcotics Information Management System [50] | Imports and exports | 2018-present | Mandatory reporting by all narcotic handlers, collecting over 120 million cases annually | Partially accessible with application through medical narcotics big data utilization service, data provided for a maximum of 1 y | Four datasets are separately available (import/export, production, sales/ purchase, and usage) | • Large sample size | • Cannot reveal temporal trends by patient since data are de-identified | [51] |
Distribution | • Holistic data collection across substance distribution systems | • Cannot reveal annual trends since data are only provided for a maximum of 1 y | ||||||
• Pharmaceutical companies | • Nationally representative sample | |||||||
• Wholesalers Prescription and dispensation data | ||||||||
• Hospitals, clinics, pharmacies | ||||||||
Report on Public Awareness of Misuse of Drugs [52] | • Perceptions on SU | Yearly reports, 2006-1 y prior to present | Web panel and phone call samples from Entire Korean population Response rate around 5%; final sample size 1000 | Report accessible through website | Q10. Experience with weight loss drugs, brain stimulants (“study aids”), other narcotics (e.g., marijuana, methamphetamine), “sobering drugs,” and synthetic novel drugs | • Yearly report | • No access to raw data | |
• Experiences of SU Statistics are reported by sex/gender and region | • Estimates of total SU prevalence in Korea | • Drug use assessed in broad categories | ||||||
• Low response rate, possible bias from data acquirement methods | ||||||||
Q11. Experience requesting over-prescription of substances | • Socioeconomic variables other than sex/gender and region not available | |||||||
Korea Adverse Events Reporting Systems Database (KAERS DB) [53] | Detection of substance misuse & morbidity | 1988-2 y prior to present | Cases reported through KAERS | Partially accessible with application (data are only within 10 y) | Demographics, substance code, results, doses and usage pattern, route of administration, indications, purpose of drug usage, adverse event information, medical history | • Nationally representative sample | • Potential underreporting (reporting usually done by healthcare providers) | [23,24,35,54] |
• Patient characteristics | ||||||||
• Type of adverse event | • Difficult to observe illicit SU | |||||||
• Mechanisms of SU | ||||||||
Narcotic Crimes Report (Prosecution Service) [4] | No. of cases of trafficking, use, or possession of an illicit substance (opioids, heroin, cocaine, amphetamine/ATS/NPS, cannabis) | Yearly reports, 2004-1 y prior to present | Cases identified and secured in law enforcement operations | Report accessible through website | N/A | • Yearly report | • No access to raw data | |
• Some data that could be used to estimate illicit drug use | • Limited to drug offenders; influenced by policies and political environment | |||||||
• Frequently cited by media (high social influence) | ||||||||
Korea Youth Risk Behavior Web-based Survey (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) [55] | Detection of SU morbidity | Every 3 y between 2005-2010, annually since 2011 | Sample of 2% of total middle and high school students (average n=77 105) | Reports, public-release research dataset | Alcohol use, mental health, SU (lifetime SU; reasons for SU; first SU) | • Focused on the youth population, which is suspected to be experiencing the most rapid SU increase | • Sample is restricted to students enrolled | [43-46] |
• Limited variables on SU | ||||||||
• Routine data collection | • Likely to be underreported | |||||||
Discharge Injury Patient Survey (Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency) [56] | Detection of substance misuse & morbidity | 2005-2 y prior to the present | Patient sample of 9% from 220 sampled hospitals (approximately n=300 000) | Public research dataset accessible with application | Demographics, diagnostic code, result of treatment, reason of injury (e.g., “poisoning”), type of poison substance | • Large sample size | • Frequent measurement error and misclassification of SU | |
• Inpatient stays | • Detailed clinical data and few missing data | |||||||
• Electronic health records | • Self-reported variables included | |||||||
• Diagnostic codes for non-fatal overdose | ||||||||
Emergency Room Injury Survey (Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency) [57] | Detection of substance misuse & morbidity | 2006-2 y prior to the present | All patients who visited 23 sample ERs (approximately n=280 000) | Public research dataset (year 2019, 2020) accessible with application | Demographics, diagnostic code, result of treatment, reason of injury (e.g., “poisoning”), type of poison substance, suicide risk factor (e.g., “drug addiction”) | • Nationally representative sample | • Frequent measurement error and misclassification of SU | |
• ER visits | • Includes the substances used | • Occupation/education documented for only 10% to 20% of sample | ||||||
• Diagnostic codes for non-fatal overdose | • Requires cleaning of manually entered data | |||||||
• Only 2 y publicly available | ||||||||
Mental Health Survey (Research and Planning Division of the Mental Health Research Institute) [58] | Detection of SU morbidity | Every 5 y (2001-2021) | Those aged 18 y to 79 y (n=5511) (2021) | Reports, public-release research dataset; Restricted dataset accessible with application | Alcohol use disorder, nicotine use disorder, suicide (2011, 2016, 2021), SUD (2016) | • Data collection extended for several years | • SUD only documented in 2016 | |
• Used in several mental health-related studies | ||||||||
Cause of Death Survey (Statistics Korea) [59] | Mortality data | Every year/month | Death, includes all reported cases | Publicly available | Death by poisonous substance, death by unknown substance, suicide by other method | • Regional/monthly data | • Does not specify substance | |
• Cause of death demographics | • Nationally representative sample | • Cause of death not sufficiently specific |
Report | Year | Study population | Content |
---|---|---|---|
Substance User Survey [5] | 2021 | 540 Adult offenders sampled from rehabilitation facilities or undergoing SUD treatment | Type of substance, SU period, gender, education, income/wealth, previous health issues, comorbid conditions, childhood experience, age of SU initiation, purchase route, etc. |
Mental Health Survey [60] | 2016 | Households from 21 community catchments throughout Korea | Past usage of any substances |
Narcotic Substances Addiction Survey [61] | 2014 | 936 Adults living in Incheon | SU prevalence estimates in Incheon |
Narcotic Substances Addiction Survey [62] | 2009 | 447 People with drug dependence in prisons, rehabilitation facilities, probation systems, and other hospital systems | Type of substance, SU period, gender, education, income/wealth, previous health issues, comorbid conditions, childhood experience, age of SU initiation, purchase route, etc. |
SU, substance use; SUD, substance use disorder; ATS, amphetamine-type stimulant; NPS, new psychoactive substance; N/A, not applicable; ER, emergency room. Data availability was assessed in December 2023.
SU, substance use; SUD, substance use disorder.