Objectives There is no systematic review on economic evaluations of telemedicine in Japan, despite over 1000 trials implemented. Our systematic review aims to examine whether Japan’s telemedicine is cost-saving or cost-effective, examine the methodological rigorousness of the economic evaluations, and discuss future studies needed to improve telemedicine’s financial sustainability.
Methods We searched five databases, including two Japanese databases, to find peer-reviewed articles published between January 1, 2000 and December 31, 2014 in English and Japanese that performed economic evaluations of Japan’s telemedicine programs. The methodological rigorousness of the economic analyses was assessed with a well-established checklist. We calculated the benefit-to-cost ratio (BCR) when a reviewed study reported related data but did not report the BCR. All cost values were adjusted to 2014 US dollars.
Results Among the 17 articles identified, six studies reported on settings connecting physicians for specialist consultations, and eleven studies on settings connecting healthcare providers and patients at home. There are three cost-benefit analyses and three cost-minimization analyses. The remaining studies measured the benefit of telemedicine only, using medical expenditure saved or users’ willingness-to-pay. There was substantial diversity in the methodological rigorousness. Studies on teledermatology and teleradiology indicated a favorable level of economic efficiency. Studies on telehomecare gave mixed results. One cost-benefit analysis on telehomecare indicated a low economic efficiency, partly due to public subsidy rules, e.g., a too short budget period.
Conclusions Overall, telemedicine programs in Japan were indicated to have a favorable level of economic efficiency. However, the scarcity of the economic literature indicates the need for further rigorous economic evaluation studies.
Summary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Key Factors Influencing the Operationalization and Effectiveness of Telemedicine Services in Henan Province, China: Cross-Sectional Analysis Xianying He, Fangfang Cui, Minzhao Lyu, Dongxu Sun, Xu Zhang, Jinming Shi, Yinglan Zhang, Shuai Jiang, Jie Zhao Journal of Medical Internet Research.2024; 26: e45020. CrossRef
Analysis of the Forces Driving Public Hospitals’ Operating Costs Using LMDI Decomposition: The Case of Japan Kiyotoshi Kou, Yi Dou, Ichiro Arai Sustainability.2024; 16(2): 853. CrossRef
Remote consultations in community mental health: A qualitative study of clinical teams Robyn McCarron, Anna Moore, Ilana Foreman, Emily Brewis, Olivia Clarke, Abby Howes, Katherine Parkin, Diana Luk, Maisie Satchwell Hirst, Emilie Sach, Aimee Shipp, Lorna Stahly, Anupam Bhardwaj Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing.2024; 31(5): 857. CrossRef
Relationship Between Clinics Offering Telemedicine and Population Density in Japan: An Ecological Study Takashi Kuwayama, Kazuhiko Kotani Telemedicine Reports.2024; 5(1): 99. CrossRef
A Study of Factors Influencing the Acceptance of non-Face-to-Face Treatment Based on Social Cognitive Theory Myung Soon Kwon, Ji Hye Jang, Hyun Sik Kim, Yeon Jeong Heo Quality Improvement in Health Care.2024; 30(1): 55. CrossRef
Case study of a healthcare virtual community model Kun-Huang Huarng, Cheng-Fang Lee, Tiffany Hui-Kuang Yu Technological Forecasting and Social Change.2023; 188: 122281. CrossRef
COVID-19 pandemic and hypertension: an updated report from the Japanese Society of Hypertension project team on COVID-19 Shigeru Shibata, Kazuo Kobayashi, Masami Tanaka, Kei Asayama, Eiichiro Yamamoto, Hironori Nakagami, Satoshi Hoshide, Takuya Kishi, Chisa Matsumoto, Masaki Mogi, Satoshi Morimoto, Koichi Yamamoto, Masashi Mukoyama, Kazuomi Kario, Koichi Node, Hiromi Rakugi Hypertension Research.2023; 46(3): 589. CrossRef
The Twenty Factors that Made Teledermatology Consultation a Matured Application: A Systematic Review Garehatty Rudrappa Kanthraj Clinical Dermatology Review.2023; 7(1): 10. CrossRef
Applications, opportunities, and challenges in using Telehealth for burn injury management: A systematic review Mohammad Hosein Hayavi-Haghighi, Jahanpour Alipour Burns.2023; 49(6): 1237. CrossRef
Economic evaluation of remote patient monitoring and organizational analysis according to patient involvement: a scoping review Myriam Le Goff-Pronost, Isabelle Bongiovanni-Delarozière International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Acceptability and feasibility of assisted telepsychiatry in routine healthcare settings in India: a qualitative study Abhijit Nadkarni, Ankur Garg, Ravindra Agrawal, Seema Sambari, Kedar Mirchandani, Richard Velleman, Devika Gupta, Urvita Bhatia, Godwin Fernandes, Ethel D’souza, Akshada Amonkar, Anil Rane Oxford Open Digital Health.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Beyond the Nuts and Bolts: Tele-Critical Care Patients, Workflows, and Activity Patterns Christina Canfield, Silvia Perez-Protto, Matthew Siuba, Steven Hata, Chiedozie Udeh Telemedicine and e-Health.2022; 28(1): 73. CrossRef
Effectiveness of Pediatric Teleconsultation to Prevent Skin Conditions in Infants and Reduce Parenting Stress in Mothers: Randomized Controlled Trial Tomohisa Ando, Rintaro Mori, Kenji Takehara, Mari Asukata, Shuichi Ito, Akira Oka JMIR Pediatrics and Parenting.2022; 5(1): e27615. CrossRef
The Willingness to Pay for Telemedicine Among Patients With Chronic Diseases: Systematic Review Valerie Chua, Jin Hean Koh, Choon Huat Gerald Koh, Shilpa Tyagi Journal of Medical Internet Research.2022; 24(4): e33372. CrossRef
Telemedicine and Community Health Projects in Asia Anil Kumar Jha, Erika Sawka, Bhagirath Tiwari, Huiting Dong, Choon Chiat Oh, Seyedali Ghaemi, Xuejiao Zhang, Adarsh Kumar Jha Dermatologic Clinics.2021; 39(1): 23. CrossRef
A new telestroke network system in northern area of Okayama prefecture Ryo Sasaki, Toru Yamashita, Yoshio Omote, Mami Takemoto, Nozomi Hishikawa, Taijun Yunoki, Kazuki Kobayashi, Takashi Sawata, Yuki Sato, Junichi Kubota, Masayuki Mizobuchi, Takashi Hayashi, Koji Abe Neurology and Clinical Neuroscience.2021; 9(2): 166. CrossRef
Opportunities and challenges for contactless healthcare services in the post-COVID-19 Era Sang M. Lee, DonHee Lee Technological Forecasting and Social Change.2021; 167: 120712. CrossRef
Creation of a Learning Environment Contributing to the Development
of Communication Competencies within the System of Continuing Education of Medical Doctors NS Zhuravskaya, MV Bektasova, BV Okun’, VA Yanovich ЗДОРОВЬЕ НАСЕЛЕНИЯ И СРЕДА ОБИТАНИЯ - ЗНиСО / PUBLIC HEALTH AND LIFE ENVIRONMENT.2021; : 95. CrossRef
Economic Aspects of Delivering Primary Care Services: An Evidence Synthesis to Inform Policy and Research Priorities LORCAN CLARKE, MICHAEL ANDERSON, ROB ANDERSON, MORTEN BONDE KLAUSEN, REBECCA FORMAN, JENNA KERNS, ADRIAN RABE, SØREN RUD KRISTENSEN, PAVLOS THEODORAKIS, JOSE VALDERAS, HANS KLUGE, ELIAS MOSSIALOS The Milbank Quarterly.2021; 99(4): 974. CrossRef
Knowledge Update on the Economic Evaluation of Pacemaker Telemonitoring Systems Antonio Lopez-Villegas, César Leal-Costa, Mercedes Perez-Heredia, Irene Villegas-Tripiana, Daniel Catalán-Matamoros International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2021; 18(22): 12120. CrossRef
Problems of development of telemedicine technologies in Russia through the prism of foreign experience O. S. Kobyakova, F. N. Kadyrov National Health Care (Russia).2021; 2(2): 13. CrossRef
Economic evaluation of E-health interventions compared with alternative treatments in older persons’ care Aziz Rezapour, Seyede Sedighe Hosseinijebeli, Saeed Bagheri Faradonbeh Journal of Education and Health Promotion.2021; 10(1): 134. CrossRef
A Multicenter Case-Historical Control Study on Short-Term Outcomes of Tele-Intensive Care Unit Awad Al-Omari, Abbas Al Mutair, Maram Al Ammary, Fadi Aljamaan Telemedicine and e-Health.2020; 26(5): 645. CrossRef
Telemedicine in the OECD: An umbrella review of clinical and cost-effectiveness, patient experience and implementation Nkiruka D. Eze, Céu Mateus, Tiago Cravo Oliveira Hashiguchi, Hannah E. Carter PLOS ONE.2020; 15(8): e0237585. CrossRef
Understanding Medical Students’ Attitudes Toward Learning eHealth: Questionnaire Study Kjeld Vossen, Jan-Joost Rethans, Sander M J van Kuijk, Cees P van der Vleuten, Pieter L Kubben JMIR Medical Education.2020; 6(2): e17030. CrossRef
Тelemedicine technologies in occupational health and pathology Sergey A. Saiganov, Vadim I. Mazurov, Viktor V. Shilov, Sergey A. Gorbanev Hygiene and sanitation.2020; 99(9): 961. CrossRef
Barriers to use of remote monitoring technologies (RMT) used to support COVID-19 patients: A rapid review (Preprint) Elizabeth Houlding, Kedar Mate, Kim Engler, David Ortiz-Paredes, Marie-Pascale Pomey, Joseph Cox, Tarek Hijal, Bertrand Lebouché JMIR mHealth and uHealth.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Feasibility of support vector machine learning in age‐related macular degeneration using small sample yielding sparse optical coherence tomography data Gwenolé Quellec, Jens Kowal, Pascal W. Hasler, Hendrik P. N. Scholl, Sandrine Zweifel, Balaskas Konstantinos, João Emanuel Ramos de Carvalho, Tjebo Heeren, Catherine Egan, Adnan Tufail, Peter M. Maloca Acta Ophthalmologica.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
Exploring the Impact of a Telehealth Care System on Organizational Capabilities and Organizational Performance from a Resource-Based Perspective Chun-Hsun Chen, Yu-Li Lan, Wei-Pang Yang, Fang-Ming Hsu, Chin-Lon Lin, Hsing-Chu Chen International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2019; 16(20): 3988. CrossRef
Addressing cost and time barriers in chronic disease management through telemedicine: an exploratory research in select low- and middle-income countries Saleem Sayani, Momina Muzammil, Karima Saleh, Abdul Muqeet, Fabiha Zaidi, Tehniat Shaikh Therapeutic Advances in Chronic Disease.2019; 10: 204062231989158. CrossRef
Estado actual de la telemedicina: ¿dónde estamos y qué nos queda por hacer? Francesc García Cuyàs, Núria Vàzquez, Marc de San Pedro, Margarita Hospedales Medicina Clínica.2018; 150(4): 150. CrossRef
State of the art of the telemedicine. Where are we and what is pending to be done? Francesc García Cuyàs, Núria Vàzquez, Marc de San Pedro, Margarita Hospedales Medicina Clínica (English Edition).2018; 150(4): 150. CrossRef
Comparison between High- and Low-Cost Transmission of Tele-Anesthesia in Japan Yoh Sugawara, Tetsuya Miyashita, Yusuke Mizuno, Yusuke Nagamine, Tomoyuki Miyazaki, Ayako Kobayashi, Kentaro Tojo, Yasuhiro Iketani, Shunsuke Takaki, Takahisa Goto Journal of Healthcare Engineering.2018; 2018: 1. CrossRef
Comparative cost-benefit analysis of tele-homecare for community-dwelling elderly in Japan: Non-Government versus Government Supported Funding Models Miki Akiyama, Chon Abraham International Journal of Medical Informatics.2017; 104: 1. CrossRef
The use of telemedicine for delivering healthcare in Japan: Systematic review of literature published in Japanese and English languages Jun Ito, Sisira Edirippulige, Takeshi Aono, Nigel R Armfield Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare.2017; 23(10): 828. CrossRef
Cancer is a leading cause of death around the world. Education is at the core of cancer prevention activities, especially programs targeting empowering existing public health workforce. In the past 10 years, researchers at the University of Pittsburgh have been building the Global Health Network Supercourse project, a library of over 4500 online lectures and a network of nearly 50000 public health professionals in 174 countries. As of November, 2010, the overall number of Supercourse participants from Asia exceeds 7000 participants. The Supercourse network has been investigating methods for Internet based recruitment of cancer prevention professionals in order to network cancer experts locally and globally, including the use of mHealth technologies for cancer research education and for NCD registries. Supercourse is a tool that can offer a solution to the challenges of information sharing, especially in the field of NCDs and cancer. In this paper, we highlight the need for the development of Cancer Supercourse with Satellite in Asia and encourage faculty members from Asia to join the network.
Summary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
mHealth taxonomy: a literature survey of mobile health applications Phillip Olla, Caley Shimskey Health and Technology.2015; 4(4): 299. CrossRef