- Factors Associated With Failure of Health System Reform: A Systematic Review and Meta-synthesis
-
Mahboubeh Bayat, Tahereh Kashkalani, Mahmoud Khodadost, Azad Shokri, Hamed Fattahi, Faeze Ghasemi Seproo, Fatemeh Younesi, Roghayeh khalilnezhad
-
J Prev Med Public Health. 2023;56(2):128-144. Published online March 14, 2023
-
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3961/jpmph.22.394
-
-
14,713
View
-
321
Download
-
24
Web of Science
-
27
Crossref
-
Abstract
PDF
- Objectives
The health system reform process is highly political and controversial, and in most cases, it fails to realize its intended goals. This study was conducted to synthesize factors underlying the failure of health system reforms.
Methods In this systematic review and meta-synthesis, we searched 9 international and regional databases to identify qualitative and mixed-methods studies published up to December 2019. Using thematic synthesis, we analyzed the data. We utilized the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research checklist for quality assessment.
Results After application of the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 40 of 1837 articles were included in the content analysis. The identified factors were organized into 7 main themes and 32 sub-themes. The main themes included: (1) reforms initiators’ attitudes and knowledge; (2) weakness of political support; (3) lack of interest group support; (4) insufficient comprehensiveness of the reform; (5) problems related to the implementation of the reform; (6) harmful consequences of reform implementation; and (7) the political, economic, cultural, and social conditions of the society in which the reform takes place.
Conclusions Health system reform is a deep and extensive process, and shortcomings and weaknesses in each step have overcome health reform attempts in many countries. Awareness of these failure factors and appropriate responses to these issues can help policymakers properly plan and implement future reform programs and achieve the ultimate goals of reform: to improve the quantity and quality of health services and the health of society.
-
Summary
-
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by 
- Governance of a health and social service system after two years of a large-scale reform: a qualitative study in Finland
Satu Paatela, Moona Huhtakangas, Liina-Kaisa Tynkkynen Journal of Health Organization and Management.2026; 40(2): 254. CrossRef - Steering health reform through policy stewardship: experience from Sanming, China
Haochen Jiang, M. Ramesh Health Economics, Policy and Law.2026; 21(3): 349. CrossRef - Healthcare professionals’ readiness for national health insurance in Malaysia: Policy implications for universal health coverage
Gho Nyong San, Yee Siew Mei, Ruth Sim, Jia Jia Lee International Journal of Healthcare Management.2026; 19(5): 1173. CrossRef - Experiences and Impacts of Working in Organisations Undergoing Regulatory Scrutiny: An Integrative Review
Gemma Stacey, Carmel Bond, Rowena Hill Journal of Advanced Nursing.2026; 82(9): 8473. CrossRef - Policy implementation is operational
Steven Were Omamo China Agricultural Economic Review.2026; : 1. CrossRef - An epidemiological review of the one health approach in emerging zoonotic diseases
Ashutosh Kumar Singh, Lokesh Kori, Evangeline Christina A, Narapity Pathirannehalage Sunil Chandra, Tarun Patil, Megha Katare Pandey, Akhlaqur Rahman, Rajnarayan R. Tiwari, Ram Kumar Nema Next Research.2026; 8: 101595. CrossRef - Navigating reform: Mental health nurses' experiences of policy-driven workforce change in community psychiatry
Walaa Badawy, Mostafa Shaban Archives of Psychiatric Nursing.2026; 61: 152104. CrossRef - Challenges in Changing Healthcare Resource Allocation – Separation, Integration, or Diversification of Institutional Logics
Villy Angelsen, Solrun Gjertine Holm Scandinavian Journal of Public Administration.2026;[Epub] CrossRef - THE PRICE OF EFFICIENCY: URBAN-RURAL DIVIDES IN LITHUANIA’S PATIENT-ORIENTED APPROACH DURING HEALTHCARE REFORM
Birutė Mockevičienė, Ilona Mulerenkienė, Romalda Kasiliauskienė, Natalja Istomina Public Policy and Administration.2026; 25(2): 180. CrossRef - Reorienting Oral Health Promotion through Systems Thinking
D. Duijster, M. de Jong-Lenters, C.M.C. Volgenant Journal of Dental Research.2026; 105(10): 1241. CrossRef - Using Systems Thinking to Advance the Prevention of Human Trafficking: Examples and a Call to Action
Elizabeth Such, Mollie Gordon, Phuong Thanh Nguyen, Lila Pavey, Jenna Hopson, Alys McAlpine, Habiba Aminu, Frances Recknor Social Sciences.2026; 15(7): 474. CrossRef - Organisational readiness for digitalisation in health care: Findings from qualitative research in four EU countries/region
Mirna Macur, Randi Lehmann Boesen, Linda Justi, Morten Sønderskov Frydensberg, Elisenda Reixach Espaulella, Mateja Bahun, Barbara Benedik, Stefania Chiappinotto, Federico Fonda, Alvisa Palese DIGITAL HEALTH.2026;[Epub] CrossRef - Are global health commitments relevant in low-income countries? Considering discussions at Davos 2026
Martina Mchenga Health Policy and Planning.2026; 41(9): 1591. CrossRef - A Formalized Pathway to Sustained Quality Improvement in Pediatric Pain Care: A ChildKind International Certification Experience
Angela Bokenfohr, Elise Kammerer, Hayley Turnbull, Jesusa Pulongbarit, Andrea Razcon Echeagaray, Tara McGrath, Dana Nagel, Calveen Basi, Erica Thomas, Maretta Walker, Alison Naylor, Christine Westerlund, Kathryn A. Birnie, Christine T. Chambers, Samina Al Canadian Journal of Pain.2026;[Epub] CrossRef - Trends in Streptococcus pneumoniae related lower respiratory infections and drug resistance among children under 5 from 1990 to 2021, and a predictive analysis for 2030
Xiaoxia Liu, Guangyan Mo, Huijing Sun, Sitong Guo, Xiaoyu Chen, Yanni Lan Italian Journal of Pediatrics.2026;[Epub] CrossRef - Health Systems Reforms in Bangladesh: An Analysis of the Last Three Decades
Treasure Udechukwu, Thierno Oumar Fofana, Louise Carnapete, Shams Shabab Haider, Suhi Hanif, Lucie Clech, Valéry Ridde Journal of Health Management.2026;[Epub] CrossRef - Impact of China’s primary healthcare reforms on utilisation, payments and self-reported health: a quasi-experimental analysis of a middle-aged and older cohort 2011–2018
Chang Cai, Christopher Millett, Shangzhi Xiong, Maoyi Tian, Jin Xu, Thomas Hone BMJ Public Health.2025; 3(1): e001595. CrossRef - Evaluating Maturity Models in Healthcare Information Systems: A Comprehensive Review
Jorge Gomes, Mário Romão Healthcare.2025; 13(15): 1847. CrossRef - Transforming Health in Post-Conflict Somalia: Priorities from a Multi-Stakeholder Roundtable on the 2025–2029 National Plan
Najib Isse Dirie, Mohamed Ahmed, Yakub Abdullahi, Jihaan Hassan, Bashiru Garba, Ahmed Adam Mohamed, Abdirazak Hersi Hassan, Amal Naleye Ali, Ali Abubakar Journal of Healthcare Leadership.2025; Volume 17: 459. CrossRef - Structural Barriers and the Future of AI in Global Health: Lessons From Eradicable Diseases
Kirubel T Hailu, Ryan R Haddad Cureus.2025;[Epub] CrossRef - Examining Bhutan’s zoonotic disease policies through a One Health lens: a qualitative policy analysis using the Policy Triangle Framework
Bir Doj Rai, Tenzin Tenzin, Dorji Tshering, Narapati Dahal, Gizachew A. Tessema, Lin Fritschi, Sylvester Dodzi Nyadanu, Gavin Pereira One Health Outlook.2025;[Epub] CrossRef - Promoting sustainable health equity: accessibility analysis and optimization of tertiary hospital networks in China’s metropolitan areas
Jiarui Han, Liping Fu, Tong Pei, Tiantian Zhang Geospatial Health.2025;[Epub] CrossRef - Reforming medical career progression: a call for merit-based systems
Francesco Maria Bulletti, Maurizio Guido, Maria Elisabetta Coccia, Antonio Palagiano, Evaldo Giacomucci, Carlo Bulletti Frontiers in Medicine.2025;[Epub] CrossRef - The Political Economy Influence on Health Policy Reform in Malaysia: The Policy Analysis and Evaluation of '1Care for 1Malaysia'
Amirul Faiz Luai, Fadhli Rusli, Nawwal Alwani Mohd Radzi, Budi Aslinie Md Sabri, Jonathan Filippon Malaysian Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences.2025; 21(5): 259. CrossRef - Perceived outcomes of medical teaching institute reforms: insights from management, faculty, and administration in Pakistani tertiary health care
Wajiha Qamar, Mehran Qayum, Waqar-un Nisa, Asma Ali BMC Health Services Research.2024;[Epub] CrossRef - Role and promise of health policy and systems research in integrating rehabilitation into the health systems
Abdul Ghaffar, Abdulgafoor M. Bachani, Adnan A. Hyder, Alarcos Cieza, Aneel Bhangu, André Bussières, Diana C. Sanchez-Ramirez, Dorcas B. C. Gandhi, Jeanine Verbunt, Kumanan Rasanathan, Louise Gustafsson, Pierre Côté, Rajiv Reebye, Roger De la Cerna-Luna, Health Research Policy and Systems.2024;[Epub] CrossRef - Inducing collective action intentions for healthcare reform through medical crowdfunding framing
Krystallia Moysidou, Smadar Cohen Chen Social Science & Medicine.2023; 333: 116090. CrossRef
|